Syrah vs. Shiraz: Same Grape, Different Styles

Confused by Syrah vs. Shiraz? Uncover the truth about this genetic twin. From the peppery hills of France to the bold vineyards of Australia, learn why one grape creates two distinct wine styles.

Hours Posted: Categories Grape and Region

This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

Walk into any wine shop, and you will see two very different bottles. One says Syrah. The other says Shiraz. They might sit on different shelves. One might feature a fancy French chateau on the label, while the other has a colorful drawing of a kangaroo or a bold, modern font. You might think they are completely different wines.

Here is the secret: They are the exact same grape.

It seems confusing, right? How can one grape have two names and taste so different? It is one of the most fascinating stories in the world of wine. It is a tale of history, climate, and culture. It is about how the exact same DNA can express itself in opposite ways depending on where it grows and who makes it.

This guide is your ultimate resource. We are going to explore everything about Syrah and Shiraz. We will look at where it came from, why it changes names, and how to pick the right bottle for your dinner. Whether you like elegant, savory wines or big, bold fruit bombs, this grape does it all.

By the end of this article, you won’t just be a wine drinker. You will be an expert on one of the world’s most popular red wines.

Core Concepts: One DNA, Two Personalities

To understand this wine, we first have to understand the grape itself. Imagine a person. If that person grows up in a cold, rainy city, they might wear coats, drink hot tea, and stay inside reading books. If that same person grows up on a sunny beach, they might wear shorts, surf, and eat fresh fruit. They are the same person, but the environment changes them.

That is exactly what happens with this grape.

The Genetics

Scientifically, the grape is known as Syrah (pronounced See-rah). That is its original name. In 1998, scientists at two major universities—UC Davis in California and Montpellier in France—did a DNA test on the grape. They found its parents.

Syrah is the child of two obscure grapes from France:

  1. Dureza: A dark-skinned grape.
  2. Mondeuse Blanche: A white grape.

Neither of these parents is famous. But their “child,” Syrah, became a superstar.

The Two Main Styles

When winemakers talk about this grape, they divide it into two camps. This helps you know what you are buying before you even pull the cork.

1. The Syrah Style (The Old World)

This is the classic French style. It is usually grown in moderate or cool climates.

  • Body: Medium to full.
  • Flavor: Tart blueberry, plum, savory olive, and smoked meat.
  • The Key Note: Black pepper. If you smell fresh cracked pepper, it’s likely Syrah.
  • Vibe: Elegant, earthy, and serious.

2. The Shiraz Style (The New World)

This is the Australian style. “Shiraz” (pronounced Shi-raz) is just the Australian name for Syrah. It is usually grown in hot climates.

  • Body: Very full, heavy, and powerful.
  • Flavor: Blackberry jam, sweet cherry, and chocolate.
  • The Key Note: Sweet spice or licorice.
  • Vibe: Bold, fruity, and friendly.

Pro Tip: Winemakers in other countries (like the USA, Chile, or South Africa) choose the name based on how the wine tastes. If a California winemaker makes a big, fruity wine, they label it Shiraz. If they make a lean, peppery wine, they label it Syrah. The name on the bottle is a hint about the style inside.

History: From Roman Roots to Australian Icons

The history of Syrah is full of myths, legends, and lucky breaks.

The Persian Myth

For a long time, people believed the grape came from the city of Shiraz in ancient Persia (modern-day Iran). It is a romantic story. Shiraz was a city famous for wine thousands of years ago. People thought Crusaders brought the vines from the Middle East to France.

It turns out, this isn’t true. The DNA testing proved the grape was born in France. However, the name “Shiraz” might have been adopted by Australians because it sounded exotic and grand.

The French Origin

Syrah was born in the Rhône Valley of France. This is a region along the Rhône River. The Romans planted vineyards there centuries ago. For a long time, Syrah was the only red grape allowed in the Northern Rhône. It was the drink of kings and popes. It was famous for being dark, inky, and able to age for decades.

The Australian Adventure

So, how did a French grape become the national symbol of Australia?

In 1832, a man named James Busby visited Europe. He is often called the “Father of Australian Wine.” He collected vine cuttings from France and brought them back to Australia. He planted them in the Sydney Botanical Gardens.

The grape loved Australia. The hot sun and dry soil were perfect for it. But the Australians didn’t call it Syrah. They called it “Scyras” at first, which eventually morphed into “Shiraz.”

For a long time, Shiraz was used to make cheap fortified wine (wine with brandy added). But in the 1950s, a winemaker named Max Schubert changed everything. He visited France and saw how great the wines could be. He went back to Australia and created a wine called Penfolds Grange.

It became the most famous wine in Australia. It proved that Shiraz could be world-class. Today, Australia has some of the oldest Shiraz vines in the world, some over 150 years old!

Cultural and Societal Impact

Syrah and Shiraz are not just agricultural products; they shape cultures.

The French Dinner Table

In France, Syrah is a food wine. It is rarely drunk on its own at a cocktail party. It is meant to be on a table with roasted lamb, wild game, or heavy stews. It represents tradition. The production is strictly controlled by laws called Appellation d’Origine Contrôlée (AOC). These laws dictate exactly how the grapes must be grown to protect the culture of the region.

The Australian Barbecue

In Australia, Shiraz is the people’s wine. It is democratic. You can buy a great bottle for $10 or a collector’s bottle for $800. It is the perfect match for the “barbie” (barbecue). It fits the Australian lifestyle—sunny, outgoing, and generous.

The “GSM” Blend

You might see bottles labeled “GSM.” This stands for Grenache-Syrah-Mourvèdre.

  • Grenache adds candied fruit and high alcohol.
  • Syrah adds structure, dark fruit, and savory notes.
  • Mourvèdre adds tannin and earthiness.

This blend started in the Southern Rhône of France (like Châteauneuf-du-Pape) but is now huge in Australia and California. It shows how Syrah plays well with others. It is the “backbone” of many great blends.

Technical Details: How the Magic Happens

How does the winemaker turn the grape into two different wines? It comes down to farming and science.

In the Vineyard (Farming)

Syrah is a vigorous vine. This means it grows wild and fast. If the farmer doesn’t cut it back, the vine will grow too many leaves and too many grapes. If a vine produces too many grapes, the flavor gets watery. The farmer has to be strict.

  • Coulure: Syrah is sensitive to a condition called coulure. This happens when the weather is bad during flowering. The flowers don’t turn into fruit, and the grape clusters look gaps.
  • Harvest Time: This is the most critical decision.
    • Pick early: The grapes have more acid and taste like fresh blueberries (Syrah style).
    • Pick late: The grapes have more sugar. Sugar turns into alcohol. The grapes shrivel slightly, tasting like raisins and jam (Shiraz style).

In the Winery (Making the Wine)

Once the grapes are picked, the winemaker has a toolbox of tricks.

1. Cold Soak

Before fermentation (turning sugar to alcohol), the winemaker might soak the grape skins in the juice while it’s cold. This extracts color. Syrah has very thick skins, so the wine is almost always a deep, dark purple.

2. Whole Bunch vs. Destemming

  • Syrah Style: Some winemakers throw the whole bunch of grapes, including the green stems, into the tank. The stems add a spicy, herbal flavor and tannin. This is common in France.
  • Shiraz Style: Winemakers usually remove all stems. They only want the berries. This makes the wine smoother and fruitier.

3. Oak Aging

Red wine is usually aged in wooden barrels. The type of wood matters immensely.

  • French Oak: The classic choice. It adds subtle flavors of clove, smoke, and cedar. It is expensive.
  • American Oak: Often used for Australian Shiraz. It is porous and strong. It adds flavors of vanilla, coconut, and dill pickle.

If you taste a Shiraz that reminds you of a chocolate-coconut candy bar, that is the mix of ripe fruit and American oak.

A Tour of the World: Major Regions

Knowing where the wine comes from tells you what it will taste like.

1. Northern Rhône Valley, France (The Homeland)

This is the holy grail for Syrah lovers. The vineyards are planted on steep granite hills. The vines have to dig deep into the rock to find water.

  • Key Regions: Hermitage, Côte-Rôtie, Cornas, Saint-Joseph.
  • Profile: Savory, smoky, bloody, flowery (violet), and mineral. Very little new oak is used.

2. Barossa Valley, Australia (The Powerhouse)

This is a hot, dry region near Adelaide. It is famous for old vines.

  • Profile: Massive wines. High alcohol (sometimes 15% or more). Flavors of blackberry jam, mocha, and tobacco.
  • Buying Tip: Look for “Barossa” on the label if you want the classic bold Shiraz experience.

3. McLaren Vale, Australia

Also in Australia, but closer to the ocean.

  • Profile: Still bold, but with more chocolate and savory earth notes compared to Barossa.

4. Paso Robles, California, USA

California has areas that get very hot, similar to Australia. Paso Robles is famous for “Rhône Rangers”—winemakers who love Rhône grapes.

  • Profile: Big, plush, and soft. Often labeled as Syrah but tastes like Shiraz.

5. Washington State, USA

A cooler region in the north.

  • Profile: This is the bridge between France and Australia. It has the fruit of the New World but the savory pepper of the Old World.

6. Chile and South Africa

These countries offer great value.

  • Chile: cool coastal areas produce peppery, elegant Syrah.
  • South Africa: often called “Syrah” but has a smoky, rubbery note that is unique to the region.

Practical Applications: Drinking and Serving

You bought the bottle. Now, how do you get the best experience?

Serving Temperature

Do not serve it too warm! If red wine is too warm (room temperature in a hot house), it tastes like alcoholic soup.

  • Ideal Temp: 60–65°F (15–18°C).
  • Tip: Put the bottle in the fridge for 20 minutes before you open it. This tightens up the flavors.

Decanting

Does it need air?

  • Young Shiraz: No, pop and pour. It is ready to go.
  • Young French Syrah: Yes. It can be “tight.” Pouring it into a decanter for an hour lets the harsh tannins soften.
  • Old Wines: If the bottle is 10+ years old, decant it gently just to remove the sediment (the grit at the bottom).

Glassware

Use a standard large red wine glass. You want a big bowl so you can swirl the wine. Swirling releases those complex aromas of pepper and spice.

Food Pairing Guide

For Syrah (Cool Climate/French):

Think distinct flavors and herbs.

  • Meat: Roast lamb with rosemary is the classic pairing. Venison or duck.
  • Vegetarian: Grilled portobello mushrooms, wild rice, dishes with black olives.
  • Cheese: Aged Gouda or sharp cheddar.

For Shiraz (Warm Climate/Australian):

Think fat, spice, and char.

  • Meat: BBQ ribs with sticky sauce. Burgers with blue cheese. Pepperoni pizza.
  • Vegetarian: Lentil stew with curry spices. Roasted eggplant.
  • Cheese: Smoked cheeses.

Future Implications: What’s Next?

The world of wine is changing, and Syrah/Shiraz is evolving too.

Climate Change

This is the biggest factor. As the world gets hotter, regions that used to be “cool” are becoming “warm.”

  • French regions are getting hotter, making French Syrah taste fruitier and higher in alcohol.
  • Australian winemakers are looking for cooler spots, climbing higher up mountains or moving closer to the ocean to keep their wines fresh.

The Shift to Elegance

For a long time, bigger was better. Critics loved high-alcohol “fruit bombs.” But tastes are changing. Modern drinkers often want wines that are lighter and easier to drink with food.

  • Australian producers are starting to pick grapes earlier to keep the acid high and alcohol low.
  • There is a trend toward “Cool Climate Shiraz” from places like the Yarra Valley in Australia.

New Regions

Keep an eye on New Zealand and Oregon. These places are famous for Pinot Noir, but they are starting to make incredible, spicy Syrahs that rival the best of France.

Conclusion: The Adventure in a Glass

Syrah and Shiraz offer a unique adventure. They teach us that biology isn’t destiny—geography is.

You can drink a Syrah from the Northern Rhône and taste the history of Romans and medieval knights. You can taste the cool granite and the smell of a French forest.

Or, you can crack open a Shiraz from Barossa and taste the Australian sunshine. You can taste the optimism, the heat, and the bold energy of the New World.

They are the same grape. They are the same DNA. But they tell two completely different stories. The best way to learn? Go buy one of each. Invite a friend over. Taste them side-by-side. That is the moment the difference becomes clear, and you truly understand the magic of wine.

Cheers!

External Links for Further Reading